Sunday, April 1, 2012

Why we don't want to eat Legumes

This is another of my posts on basic Primal notes. All of these are condensed versions of the information I found on (which is why you see the image here as well.)  All direct quotes will be given in italics.

 This is not going to be a long post because even though there are 10 pages of listings for posts when you search for "legumes", most only mention them.

I spent several hours hunting through the site and reading about 30 different posts, but for all that time spent, I can't say I found much actual information on legumes, however what I did find was probably enough to form an opinion.

First, it's clear after a bit of reading that Mark himself doesn't eat legumes because they don't agree with him, not necessarily because they are not worth eating. Since they are not one of the things that are part of his diet he doesn't seem to spend much time talking about them.  For instance there is no "definitive guide to legumes" as there is for grains and oil which are the other NO NOs.

What I found about legumes :
  • If you have to choose between legumes and grains you definitely are better of choosing legumes. Just as there are better and worse grains, there are also better and worse legumes.
  • The best legumes - Fresh green beans and peas. These are a lot lower in carbs than dried and easier to digest.
  • The worst legumes - Dried beans and peanuts. 
Beans do contain some protein and are edible if you don't have any other options, but they are also difficult to digest and therefore need to be well soaked and cooked the proper way otherwise you will have to deal with unpleasant side effects such as gas. They are also very high in carbs.

Peanuts have lots of allergens and Mark considers them on the same level as cereal grains.  The photo above might seem a bit dramatic, but the truth is that peanuts can be life threatening.

One thing that really surprised me was that in one post he said that legumes "fall into the O.K. category with wine, chocolate, cheese and other dairy."

Really? I know dairy and therefore cheese causes problems for some people, but lumping wine and chocolate in there as well really threw me for a loop. I would think that on a scale of worse to best, chocolate and wine, both of which have been shown to have health benefits, would be far ahead of legumes which don't seem to have much of anything to contribute other than a small amount of protein and a lot of problematic digestive issues.

But then again I guess it depends on how you look at it.  Certainly if you're starving and beans are all you have then they will at least give you some nutrition, whereas making a dinner out of red wine and chocolate - much as I love the thought - probably not such a great idea.

I think the point is that none of the above are as good nutritionally as the Primal basics - meat, poultry, fish, eggs and vegetables - and therefore should, in the 80/20, plan be considered part of the 20% and not the 80%.

I only found two posts with any really helpful information :

My Plan of Action :
  • If I am ever in the position to have to choose between grains and legumes, legumes are the best choice.
  • I have never really liked beans or other legumes, so this just gives me all the more reason to not eat them.
  • Peanuts are a legume and since they also cause a lot of deadly reactions, I'm treating them like poison. I definitely will not be feeding them to guests either since I really don't want to have to rush anyone to the hospital in the middle of a party. "When in doubt, do without." as my Mother used to say.
  • Fresh green beans, peas and pea pods are the least harmful and since they do contain nutrients, I'm going to included them a couple of times a week for variation, especially in stir-fry which I love. And since they are part of the 20%, I'll have my stir-fry dinner without the wine (which really doesn't go with it anyway.)

 “Life isn't about finding yourself.  Life is about creating yourself.”   - George Bernard Shaw

Want to try Paleo, but .....

... think it's too hard to do?
... don't have enough information?
... don't know where to start?
My STEP-BY-STEP PALEO ebook course makes it Easy !

I show you exactly what to do Step by Step,
I give you lots of great Recipes,
and I make it Fun !

check out Book 1 on Amazon today !


1 comment:

  1. Thanks for the information, it's helping me to form an action plan as I begin to travel this path.


Valid comments are always encouraged and welcome, but please remember this is not a platform for self-promotion. All comments are moderated, and those with links that are not relevent to the content on this blog WILL NOT be published.